Scottish Independence (the sequel)

(04-12-2013 19:32 )Tutankamon Wrote:  Officials emphasised that Scotland’s entry would require unanimous agreement of all the 28 existing members."

And Spain is a member of NATO as well..........

(04-12-2013 23:06 )The Silent Majority Wrote:  

(04-12-2013 19:32 )Tutankamon Wrote:  Officials emphasised that Scotland’s entry would require unanimous agreement of all the 28 existing members."

And Spain is a member of NATO as well..........

Yeah, the Catalonia situation will be uppermost on their minds right now. Can't have those pesky Scots setting a precedent

Thank you very much for my nomination in
Best Cap or Cap Set Of The Year 2013
for Dannii Harwood Posts 781 & 782

looks like the Partys in England are about to put a huge hole in the scotland wanting to keep the pound after independance basically saying you cant have monatary union cant blame them to be honest

This seems to be an odd tactic by England. By sticking two fingers up to the Scots they've jeopardised keeping a handle on north sea oil and also sharing the British debt.

Alex Salmond will go straight into the Euro. A few years ago this would've been inconceivable but now the financial crisis is effectively over and economic growth is back across the Euro zone.

It looks to me like England now thinks independence is a reality and this threat is an attempt to scare the Scots into staying in the UK.

Independence - bring it on!

(12-02-2014 23:10 )Digital Dave Wrote:  This seems to be an odd tactic by England. By sticking two fingers up to the Scots they've jeopardised keeping a handle on north sea oil and also sharing the British debt.

Alex Salmond will go straight into the Euro. A few years ago this would've been inconceivable but now the financial crisis is effectively over and economic growth is back across the Euro zone.

It looks to me like England now thinks independence is a reality and this threat is an attempt to scare the Scots into staying in the UK.

Independence - bring it on!

Nah not scare tactics just stating the fact that if was currency union would have tobe joint policy on tax and spend and other political things thought thats what independence was for so you could make these decisions yourselfs

The english have been for independence since was announced think we are at the point in relationships where we know your going to leave just wish you would fuck off so we get on with life

How could Salmond go straight into the Euro when it's impossible to meet the criteria? For a start, you would need need to join the ERM and "shadow" the Euro(within +/-15%) for 2 years, which is a bit hard to do without your own currency...

Then there's the requirement to be an EU member, which can't be done overnight.

Why would an independent Scotland want the UK pound anyway?

It's a bit like when a teenager decides to leave home and be independant. They still want to bring all their dirty washing home and go to mum when they are short of money

Because they think a Scottish currency could never be seen as established and as credible as the UK pound and as a small independent currency it would face more risks and as a result have a dangerous lack of stability. Although in fact small countries with strong and stable currencies do exist, such as the Swiss franc, the Norwegian krona and the Singapore dollar for example.

(13-02-2014 14:17 )dominar rygel xvi Wrote:  Why would an independent Scotland want the UK pound anyway?

becasue your biggest sectors are oil tourism and financial services the last 2 would be better if you used stirling as with the dollar and euro its one of the go to currencys

as most tourists to scotland are usally from US and the far east and most come thru england first would be a ball ache to change currency as soon as u hit gretna green

you could go for the euro but as the majorty of your exports would be to uk then would affect them