Well done to Alice. I've enjoyed her performances this year.
And well done to Eyres too. I thought the group approach was something different and would work well if there were second and third seeds in every group based on number of votes cast in the first round, as winsaw suggests.
Thought about seeding and 2 going through from each group but think you run the risk of it becoming a bit predictable/long winded.
(23-12-2017 17:26 )Joey 27 Wrote: [ -> ]We have just seen a girl who has only done about 15 nightshows on BS this year make the final of the Ultimate babe competition which i find baffling, but that's a another debate for another time, anyway im not a big fan of Alice these days but congrats to her
Yes, it's slightly odd that we might have Scarlett winning the Ultimate Babe 2017 award when she didn't even make the final of Queen of Babestation 2017, but voting I guess can always throw up inconsistencies. Either way, Alice deserves it and so does Scarlett if she wins ultimate babe
Scarlett's appearances were shared between S66 in the first half of the year, and she only moved to BS in May, so she is more qualified to the ultimate title than one tied to one particular channel.
As for Alice, she wasn't really interesting to me when she first came to BS but has grown on me so I think well done to her for getting the votes.
And re. the xpanded vote that I ran, you can see that the girls I voted for didn't do very well so at least you can't accuse it of being rigged
But if the same system is used each year, whatever it may be, that makes it fair, and the point of it is that you only need to post once.
(23-12-2017 20:16 )crankshaft Wrote: [ -> ] (23-12-2017 17:26 )Joey 27 Wrote: [ -> ]We have just seen a girl who has only done about 15 nightshows on BS this year make the final of the Ultimate babe competition which i find baffling, but that's a another debate for another time, anyway im not a big fan of Alice these days but congrats to her
Yes, it's slightly odd that we might have Scarlett winning the Ultimate Babe 2017 award when she didn't even make the final of Queen of Babestation 2017, but voting I guess can always throw up inconsistencies. Either way, Alice deserves it and so does Scarlett if she wins ultimate babe
its true people vote differently in channel and all show votes, Rebecca got so many more votes than any other girl in the ultimate day girl vote but only got to the quarterfinal of the 66 vote
(23-12-2017 20:12 )eyres42 Wrote: [ -> ]Thought about seeding
the advantage in seeding which i must admit is not something i like, but in your new system it would lessen the chances of a group of death,
please dont get me wrong i think you did a good job and its good to see a new system, i guess as its new it was always going to cause debate
Joey 27 Wrote:I was very happy with the Xpanded babe of the year winner this year even though i don't really like the format 
Well, you cancel me out then
(23-12-2017 20:29 )circles_o_o_o Wrote: [ -> ]But if the same system is used each year, whatever it may be, that makes it fair, and the point of it is that you only need to post once.
Laziness gets my vote... er...
I mean, at least the ol' forum awards were just a simple race to the end, or maybe people would prefer a mass vote with the prospect of "oh no I've been drawn against skully/Joey/Rammy/cw/etc" all the time? Assuming that didn't use to happen.
Congrats to Alice
Thanks to eyeres42 for running the comp
I think those whinging about the format would have had more credibility if they'd aired their concerns at the start, rather than after the winner was announced
(24-12-2017 12:20 )The Silent Majority Wrote: [ -> ]I think those whinging about the format would have had more credibility if they'd aired their concerns at the start, rather than after the winner was announced
That's a silly thing to say as it was a new format it was impossible to pass comment on it until people had seen how it was going to work,